Start ‘Em, Sit ‘Em Week 15: Final Verdict on Shaky Stars for Playoff Run

Now is not the time to make a bad decision with a fantasy lineup with the playoffs underway.

Like any week in the fantasy world, inconsistent superstars will make life difficult on owners this week. But there is one problem—this is lose or go home territory, as opposed to the suiting-it-up and trying again next week owners get away with in the regular season.

As such, the teeth-grinding decisions require more analysis and examination than ever. Like any savvy owner knows, going to a one-stop shop is much easier than making the rounds to various sources.

Start and sit this weekend with caution, but at least go in with an informed outlook. Good luck.

Note: All fantasy scoring info courtesy of ESPN standard leagues. Points against info courtesy of ESPN.


Start ‘Em: Andrew Luck, Indianapolis Colts (vs. HOU)

Indianapolis Colts second-year man Andrew Luck is a tough nut to crack.

While a sound option with Reggie Wayne on the field, Luck has since taken a fantasy nosedive with Wayne out. He has scored 10 or more points in seven straight games, but quarterbacks are deep enough to where that sort of production is simply not good enough.

In Week 14, Luck did right by owners brave enough to start him and was the second-highest scorer at his position with 32 points. The main component of his success? The emergence of young receivers Da’Rick Rogers (six catches, 107 yards and two scores) and LaVon Brazill (three for 53 and two).

With new weapons in tow, Luck is a must-start option. Houston allows 14.7 points to the position on average, but Luck torched the Texans for 24 fantasy points back in Week 9. Oh, and the Bengals allow just 14.4. Get Luck in those lineups.

Sit ‘Em: Tom Brady, New England Patriots (at MIA)

Winslow Townson-USA TODAY Sports

Tom Brady is back to fantasy irrelevancy with the news that tight end Rob Gronkowski is out for the year according to ESPN’s Adam Schefter:

MRI on Rob Gronkowski confirmed torn ACL, torn MCL. Season done.

— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) December 9, 2013

ESPN does an adequate job of expanding on how Gronkowski‘s loss hurts Brady:

Losing Rob Gronkowski is a huge loss for the Patriots, but especially Tom Brady, as seen here. Thanks to @ESPNMag.

— ESPN Stats & Info (@ESPNStatsInfo) December 10, 2013

Not enough to sway Brady owners? Week 15 is a date with Miami, a top-five defense against the position with an average of 12.4 points allowed.

Brady scored just six points in Week 8 against the Dolphins. Look elsewhere.

Running  Backs

Start ‘Em: DeMarco Murray, Dallas Cowboys (vs. GB)

Mike DiNovo-USA TODAY Sports

DeMarco Murray has now received 14 or more carries in his past four games and turned it into 12 or more points in each.

It is about time the Dallas coaching staff figured out they have a talented running back.

Before Week 10, Murray had scored 10 or more points just four times and was held to six or fewer in five.

Keep believing in Murray. The coaching staff is clearly intent on using him, and Week 15 sees him go against Green Bay, a defense that allows an average of 17.4 points to the position. Just nine teams allow more.

Sit ‘Em: Ryan Mathews, San Diego Chargers (at DEN)

Robert Hanashiro-USA TODAY Sport

Ah yes, San Diego Chargers running back Ryan Mathews. Sometimes owners love to call the Fresno State product “Mr. Inconsistent.”

That is totally a lie, but Mathews’ value is not. Simply put, he cannot be trusted.

Mathews scored in the top 10 last week with 19 points against a shaky New York Giants defense. While great, it does not change the fact he has scored nine or fewer points in five contests sprinkled throughout his schedule.

Week 15 has the makings of one such contest. Denver allows 18.3 points on average to the spot, but Mathews managed just 11 back in Week 10. Now on the road, there is no guarantee he will find the end zone again against the Broncos.

Wide Receivers

Start ‘Em: DeSean Jackson, Philadelphia Eagles (at MIN)

Jeffrey G. Pittenger-USA TODAY S

DeSean Jackson’s stock has wildly fluctuated all season in part to quarterback changes and the fact Nick Foles is simply better buds with Riley Cooper.

All kidding aside, Jackson posted 11 points against Detroit in a blizzard last week. It was the first time he had hit double-digit points since Week 10.

But here is the thing with Jackson—all of his double-digit outings have come in pairs this year. Check it:

DeSean Jackson Fantasy Production 2013
1 @Wsh 16
2 SD 25
3 KC 6
4 @Den 3
5 @NYG 19
6 @TB 18
7 Dal 2
8 NYG 6
9 @Oak 21
10 @GB 14
11 Wsh 8
12 BYE
13 Ari 3
14 Det 11


The trend will hold up, especially in Week 15 against a Minnesota defense that allows an average of 25.2 points to the position. Three teams allow more.

Sit ‘Em: Marques Colston, New Orleans Saints (at STL)

Derick E. Hingle-USA TODAY Sport

Hey, New Orleans Saints wide receiver Marques Colston decided to show up last week. Colston exploded for 24 points—against Carolina, of all teams.

It was only the third time all year Colston broke the 10-point barrier. The other two came in Week 1 and 10. So much for consistency.

Colston is mired in a pass-happy attack with a wealth of weapons.

Now he faces a gritty St. Louis secondary that allows 21 points to the position on average. Don’t think Colston has suddenly turned things around because owners are in the playoffs. Colston remains nothing but a solid bench player.

Tight Ends

Start ‘Em: Jordan Cameron, Cleveland Browns (vs. CHI)

Andrew Weber-USA TODAY Sports

Jason Campbell returns for Cleveland and good things happen for Jordan Cameron owners.

Cameron posted 18 points in Week 14 against New England, catching all nine of his targets as Campbell’s favorite option over the middle. It was his first time over eight points since Week 8.

With Campbell healthy, Cameron is a surefire No. 1 tight end, especially against a Chicago defense that allows an average of 8.4 points to the spot.

Sit ‘Em: Garrett Graham, Houston Texans (at IND)

Matthew Emmons-USA TODAY Sports

There is a reason Garrett Graham is owned in just 33.4 percent of leagues.

While Graham was a top-five scorer in Week 14 among names like Jimmy Graham thanks to his 13 points, it is not a sign the Wisconsin product has suddenly turned things on for the playoffs.

In fact, it was only Graham’s third venture over 10 points this season. Now he encounters an Indianapolis defense that held him to four points in Week 9.

Follow @Chris_Roling

Leave a comment

300-101   400-101   300-320   300-070   300-206   200-310   300-135   300-208   810-403   400-050   640-916   642-997   300-209   400-201   200-355   352-001   642-999   350-080   MB2-712   400-051   C2150-606   1Z0-434   1Z0-146   C2090-919   C9560-655   642-647   100-101   CQE_Exam   CSSLP